Bathtub Refinishing vs. Replacement: What’s the Best Option?

If you're considering updating your bathtub, several options are available—each with its process, cost, and durability. Here’s a simplified breakdown of the most common methods: Bath Fitter, spray refinishing, our unique pour-on refinishing process, and full bathtub replacement.

1. Bath Fitter

Bath Fitter is a custom solution that installs an acrylic liner over your existing tub, but it's not necessarily a fast option.

• Process: While installation takes only one day, it requires measuring your existing tub, sending the dimensions to create a custom acrylic liner, and waiting to be fabricated. This can take time, and if any errors occur, further delays can result.
• Durability: Acrylic liners are relatively durable and last 10-15 years. However, since the liner is installed over your current tub, it won't address any cracks or damage underneath. Over time, moisture can get trapped between the liner and the tub, potentially leading to mold or mildew growth.
• Cost: Ranges from $1,500 to $4,000.

2. Traditional Spray Method Refinishing

Spray refinishing involves applying a thin layer of acrylic or enamel over your bathtub.

• Process: A technician sprays a thin coating over the tub. Strong fumes are often involved, and homeowners may need to leave the house.
• Durability: Spray finishes last around 5-7 years but may chip or peel over time.
• Cost: Typically $300 to $700.

3. Our Pour-On Refinishing Method

At BathtubSolution.com, we use a pour-on refinishing method that creates a much thicker and more durable coating.

• Process: A thick coating layer is poured and spread evenly across the tub. Our process is odorless, dust-free, and noise-free, allowing you to stay in your home during refinishing.
• Durability: Lasts 10-15 years or more, resisting chips and peeling far better than spray methods.
• Cost: Between $400 to $750.

4. Full Bathtub Replacement

Replacing a bathtub involves removing the old tub and installing a new one.

• Process: The old tub will be fully demolished, followed by the installation of a new one. This can take 5-7 days or more.
• Durability: A new tub lasts 20+ years.
• Cost: Typically $2,000 to $7,000, including labor and materials.

Which Option Is Right for You?

• Refinishing is a great option for a quick, affordable update. For the most durable, odorless option, consider our pour-on refinishing method.
• A Bath Fitter can be a solution, but it requires time for measuring, fabrication, and installation and may not address the underlying issues with your tub.
• Full replacement is best for structural issues or major bathroom renovations.

For a cost-effective, long-lasting solution, choose our pour-on refinishing process. BathtubSolution.com offers expert refinishing services in Chicago’s north suburbs and Wisconsin. Call us today at (773) 954-3631 to schedule your service!